Welcome

My name is Nick Doran, and I am the former president of the UCSD Casual Golf Club.

I am going to post rules decisions as I encounter them on the golf course. I am pretty sure that I will be able to come up with at least one rule nugget for each round that I play.

Saturday, March 30, 2019

3/30/2019 - Terminology

I can get used to "Penalty Area" rather than hazard, but I don't know why they needed to change it.

But watching the #DellMatchPlay, I can't get used to hearing "tie" the hole.  The announcers have slipped up several times and said "halved."  Why change the terminology? 

Most of the rule changes were to speed up the game, or make it more accessible.  Is "Halved" too pretentious?  Is the new terminology more mainstream?  If it is, then I guess that's why they changed it.  But like putting with the flagstick in, it's going to take some getting used to.

Saturday, March 9, 2019

3/9/2019 - The Golf Club of California

Our club has adopted a couple of the optional local rules for 2019, and this was the first tournament that they were in effect.

One is the two-stroke penalty for a lost ball or OB, rather than stroke and distance.  I think this is a great rule for pace of play.  It was not utilized in our foursome.

The other one is a max score of 9 on any hole.  This is another one that I think is great for pace of play.  There were a couple of new players in our foursome, so this was utilized a number of times.  I had a legit 9.  I would like to not utilize this new local rule, but I'm glad it's there.

We have also had a local rule for quite some time that treats unpaved cart paths the same as paved cart paths (free relief)  That is a good local rule for this course, as a lot of the cart paths are dirt.  That one didn't come into play for us this round.

Monday, March 4, 2019

3/3/2019 - The Golf Course of California

Our club is playing GCC next week, and I had never played there, so I thought I would get in a practice round on Sunday afternoon.

When I checked in, the guy at the counter gave me a yardage book, and pointed out that there is a sand trap in the middle of the green on #7 (par 3).  He was very clear that you are not allowed to chip on the green.  If you're on the wrong side of the bunker, then you have to putt around it, he said.  He did offer the alternative of trying to putt really hard through the bunker, which would probably leave your ball in the bunker*.  And then you could use your wedge.

It is clearly stated on the scorecard (in all caps, even) - "CHIPPING ON ANY PUTTING SURFACE IS PROHIBITED."

Can they do that?  Rule 13.1f (2019 rules) covers the wrong putting green, but that's different.  PGA tour pros will often use a wedge on the green, if they would otherwise have to putt through the fringe or whatnot.

To me, this is fundamentally changing the rules of golf.  Unless otherwise specified in the rules, you can use any club for any shot.  I did a fair amount of searching and googling, and I can't find anything that convinces me that this is not a fundamental change to the rules of golf.

Should you do it?  No.  I think the course is within their rights to prohibit this.  But it's allowed in the rules of golf.  So if I was playing for $100 per hole, then I would absolutely violate their rule and post my score with a clear conscience.  I would repair any damage done to the best of my ability, and hope that they didn't kick me off the property.

Fortunately, I did not have to deal with this scenario.  I missed to the right of the green, but above the bunker.  And I would certainly have putted around the bunker in a practice round.  And if it happens in our tourney next week, I won't use a wedge on the green.  I'm not that good.  And I probably want to go back.  I really enjoyed my round there, despite the light rain and cool temperatures.

They also returned my sweatshirt, which I left in my cart, so I like the place.

*There is a noticeable elevation difference between the front and back of the green, so I suppose if you were above the trap, putting downhill, you might have a chance of putting over the bunker.  But there's no way to stop the ball, unless you can put backspin on a putt.